Because I have only gone to trial on a wheelchair tipover case once in the more than 150 lawsuits on which I served as an expert witness that involved this scenario – in a case 25 years ago – I never get to opine that I am certain that I could teach a handful of Middle School C-students how to secure almost any wheelchair to a vehicle’s floor – assuming it contained the basic equipment, in working order – in 15 minutes. This opinion would likely be challenged, the trial would be paused, and it would resume again once the court produced a handful of such students, where I could prove or disprove my opinion. I own a clean, operable set of several generations of wheelchair securement technology. I can transport it, ship it or borrow something like it almost anywhere in the World. So setting this up in a U.S. courtroom would be a cinch.
One curious consequence of the extremely limited number of variables involved in wheelchair securement is that “advances” in technology have actually made the task of securing a wheelchair more difficult. And certain benchmark changes have made it less safe. I was reminded of the decline in this activity when I recently examined a vehicle with the most ratty securement equipment I had seen for a while – a badly-damaged vehicle that appeared to be about 20 to 25 years old, and which I think would be hard to sell for anything other than its scrap value. Yet its missing, broken, severely-rusted components actually made it easier to secure certain types of wheelchairs to its floor– particularly those wheelchairs with a distance of more than 21 inches between the best, or sometimes deliberately-designed securement points, where even the dumbest driver could identify them. Unless someone, like myself, has spent his or her entire career dealing with accessible transportation, securing a wheelchair with the most obvious securement points 21 or more inches apart into a vehicle with clean, modern equipment with every piece present and fitting together with every other piece could be challenging.
Apart from tight schedules (in almost every one of the 150-plus wheelchair tipovers cases I have been involved in, the schedules were too tight), and deliberate attempts of company owners in certain sectors (particularly non-emergency medical transportation, or NEMT, service) to sabotage their drivers’ ability to secure a wheelchair, a major factor between wheelchair securement and its failure is the difference between (a) the longitudinal distance between securement points, and (b) the longitudinal distance between holes or ovals for attaching “tie-down” fittings into.
Most ancient and modern tie-down units – the industry standard is to attach two to the front corners of the chair, and two to the rear corners of the chair – contain four components: (a) the fitting that plugs into or over the holes in or ovals on the floor hardware; (b) a metal housing into which the securement straps are retracted, and from which they are pulled out of; (c) a “J-hook” (to attach to the safest and most-appropriate points on the wheelchair’s frame, and (d) the strap that can be pulled out of the retractor to reach each securement point on the wheelchair.
What makes this device interesting is that the industry standard for the longitudinal distance between holes in or ovals on the floor fittings is 48 inches. A few vehicles – including some very old ones, as well as many transit buses – have attachment points in the floor hardware (holes, ovals or even “female” belt buckles) further apart longitudinally. But most modern equipment in pristine condition (most of what I examine is not remotely in such condition) includes four sets of tie-downs that are each 13 ½ inches long – two for the front corners of a wheelchair’s structure, and two for the rear corners. These “tie-downs” are to be used in a securement space that is, in most cases, only 48 inches long. But here’s the rub: The distance between securement points on some wheelchairs is more than 21 inches long. So what, you say? So let’s do the math:
- The securement area is 48 inches long
- Each pair of tie-downs at the front and rear of a wheelchair total 27 inches in length
Now here is the interesting part: The length of strap that can be pulled out of each retractor is almost always more than two feet in length. This means that if one placed a typical wheelchair (if there was such a thing) in the center of a securement area practically double the length of the industry standard, one could pull out the straps in each retractor so much that they could reach the securement points on a wheelchair designed for Goliath. And no wheelchair securement area I have ever seen or heard of is remotely this long. Otherwise, one can make the “tie-downs” as long as they would ever need to be, to reach the securement points on any conceivable wheelchair (as long as it had some part of its structure that could serve as points to which the wheelchair-end of the tie-downs (typically rubberized “J-hooks”) could be attached. In other words, for all practical purposes – unless the strap is stuck and one cannot pull enough of it out of the retractor, or it became tangled up inside the retractor at some early point in its removal – one can make the tie-down as long as it could possibly be needed. The problem is that, while one can make the tie-down as long as he or she would ever need it to be, one cannot make it any shorter. Yet for no reason I can possibly explain, even as I’m sure that they cost more, even the length of “J-hooks” has increased by nearly three full inches over the decades.
In other words, with a modern securement area and system, the industry-standard longitudinal distance of the securement area and modern equipment, after squeezing the tie-downs to their shortest length – with not a millimeter of the strap or belt protruding from any of the four retractors, there is only 21 inches to “play with.” Translating this into wheelchair-friendly terminology, if the securement points on a wheelchair are 21 or more inches apart, most drivers cannot secure the wheelchair.
As even a further excursion into the oddity of wheelchair securement, a project conducted near the turn of the century – named the “So-What” project – produced raw specifications for a “transportable wheelchair.” The significant feature of such a chair was a specially-made, and easily-identifiable, set of securement points – one at each corner of the chair, and high enough to approximate the ideal oblique height for attaching each of the four J-hooks to the chair. The problem is – and I will never know if this even occurred to any of the genuine experts involved in this project – that many wheelchair manufacturers producing such chairs have place these clearly-identifiable securement points outside of the chair’s structure – or at least further outside the most logical point, at each corner (or wheel position) to which a tie-down’s J-hook would normally be attached. In other words, not only did the tie-downs get longer as the technology “improved,” but the securement points on the most modern wheelchairs often got further apart. Since, again, one cannot make a tie-down unit any shorter, not only did longer and longer tie-downs compound the problem, but wheelchair design compounded it – making securement more and more difficult, and for most drivers, impossible. The better we think we did, the worse we did. Actually, not a bad song title for certain genres. But a bad concept for wheelchair securement. Ironically, the ratty hardware I find on dilapidated vehicles, where the retractor fittings are rusted in place, or impossible for a normal person to extract from the track, often contain shorter tie-downs – as the photographs above illustrate: Three inches shorter on each end expands the distance which a wheelchair’s securement points can extend, and still be properly secured – by six full inches.
Since those involved in public transportation (at all levels) rarely qualify as experts in rocket science, there is a natural tendency to keep things simple –particularly for drivers often, if not commonly, paid the minimum wage. Yet during the decade I directed the operations of my own 70-vehicle paratransit system, transporting 1100 passengers a day, with roughly 150 of them wheelchair users, I had my own system of informing drivers of precisely where to attach the hooks at the ends of all four tie-downs units to every chair. I called it “red nail polish” drill. I bought a gross of cheap red nail polish at the nearby COSTCO, and whenever a new wheelchair user was added to our system, I or one of the handful of brilliant dispatchers I employed to examine the chair and mark the safety securement points at each corner of the chair with red nail polish. The drivers were also given a bottle of this polish: Over time, as the polish got scraped off (I don’t recall whether the “J-hooks” our equipment that we used at that time was rubber-coated), the drivers would repaint the optimum securement points on the chair. This was the tiniest slice of maintenance, and thus hard to monitor. But we did the best we could – mostly by thinning our drivers’ ranks by terminating the employment of whose drivers who seemed to not care enough about the passengers to keep me or, more likely, our dispatch staff, happy. But no one does things like this today. So the securement equipment has to be better. Unfortunately, as time has passed, it has gotten worse in a few important ways.
Also ironic is the fact that on ratty vehicles converted by individuals knowing nothing about wheelchair securement, or an occasional vehicle converted by someone aware of this irony, the securement tracks have been placed a few inches further apart than the industry standard, and the ADA (less important than the industry standard for most wheelchair securement issues), require them to be. So, for example, if you couple a securement area with 51 inches between the tracks, and four tie-downs so old that the “J-hooks” are not even rubber coated, and with “J-hooks” less than 5 ½ inches long, you have an extra nine inches to play with. And other than one 50-inch-long motorized scooter I saw about 25 years ago that he NO securement points of any kind on it (the housing resembled a small racing car, where the body came close to the ground on all sides), securement points are almost never 30 inches apart. So oddly, were multiple components of securement systems 20 to 25 years old rusted, broken, incompatible or missing, older securement equipment far more easily accommodates wheelchairs with an unusually long longitudinal distance between its front and rear securement points.
For someone like myself – having been involved, at some level, in wheelchair transportation for literally half a century — the mismatch of wheelchair securement points gradually getting further and further apart, combined with longer and longer tie-downs which leave less and less space between the ends of both pair to a wheelchair’s securement points to lie, is not likely to be a problem. Having seen hundreds and hundreds of wheelchairs of all types and sizes (although I have never seen a small child’s wheelchair in real life), I can almost always find some point on any wheelchair’s structure to which the ends of a “J-hook” or other hook can be attached – even while attaching these hooks to odd places on a chair does not represent optimal safety. And I suspect that there is some wheelchair “out there” which I could never figure out how to secure.
At the same time, I am not the average driver. When I examine a securement system, since the vehicle is not moving, it is not running behind schedule (as most vehicles whose securement systems I examine were when the tipover occurred). I had the experience of using or examining multiple generations of securement systems – as well as some Rube Goldberg pseudo-securement systems like a bar that moves up or down by turning a single wing nut around a screw more than a foot long as the bar is twisted upward and tightened against the underside of a wheelchair’s seat. I am not paid the minimum wage for doing this, as many or most drivers of such vehicles are (a wage still $7.25/hour in certain parts of the country). And I owned and operated a 70-vehicle paratransit system for 10 years.
As a consequence, I hardly had to work, untrained, with little experience, with old, rusty, broken securement hardware with missing pieces, with pieces that did not fit together, with retractors rusted in place, with hex-tracks filled with dirt, petrified chewing gum, twigs, tiny wads of paper and you-name-it. And I never had to work under all these conditions for a boss who couldn’t care about the risks any passengers faced as long as he or she could scratch out a living from this masquerade of a transportation system – much less a boss whose company was paid for a trip on the basis of mileage, where not a dime was earned doing anything safety-related or safety-irrelevant if the vehicle was not moving, much less a boss who ensured that this time would never be squandered by sabotaging the securement system so that the most well-intentioned and best-trained driver could never secure a wheelchair of any kind in that space with that equipment. Yet these are among the conditions in which drivers who do not secure, or who do not properly secure, wheelchairs often find themselves.
Growing up in the “Analog Age” (even if no period of time is classified this way) and working in a largely analog professional (the first Waymos only emerged a few years ago, while most of the autonomous motorcoaches introduced into Europe years ago have been removed from service), I can become mighty grumpy about changes in technology. At times, this can take extreme form: My father was a mechanical engineer, with multiple patents, who specialized in packaging. So I will never again buy a food item in some container that I cannot open without a tool.
Otherwise, the lesson that helps to explain why public transportation (at least in the U.S.) lies at the bottom of the Deep State is that “new” is not necessarily “better.” I believe strongly that this parable became more true as the United States became the country of money instead of the country of values that it faded in and out of being throughout its young lifespan. One finds this in many aspects of various modes of public transportation. But one finds it most easily when he or she examines an accessible vehicle.
The old gray mare, she ain’t what she used to be. But she can no longer run. Or change direction quickly. Or buck. So she is easier to ride and not fall off of, even without a saddle. Youth and speed are not everything. And when things go too fast, other things fall off more easily. Or tip over.